经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术的学习曲线分析

doi:10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-6899.2022.05.004

中华腔镜外科杂志(电子版) ›› 2022, Vol. 15 ›› Issue (05) : 270 -274. doi: 10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-6899.2022.05.004

论著

经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术的学习曲线分析

李陈钰¹, 贺青卿², 庄大勇², 周鹏², 岳涛², 邵长秀¹, 刘永祥¹, 徐婧², 李小磊²^,^†(

)

^1. 121000　锦州医科大学联勤保障部队第九六〇医院研究生培养基地；250031　济南，解放军联勤保障部队第九六〇医院甲乳外科
^2. 250031　济南，解放军联勤保障部队第九六〇医院甲乳外科

收稿日期:2022-02-17 出版日期:2022-10-30
通信作者: 李小磊
基金资助:
国家重点研发计划专项课题(2019YFC0119205); 国家自然科学基金项目(81702448); 济南市临床医学科技创新计划(202019010); 原济南军区总医院院长基金资助项目(2016ZD02, 2017MS04)

A prospective study of learning curve of transoral robotic thyroidectomy

Chenyu Li¹, Qingqing He², Dayong Zhuang², Peng Zhou², Tao Yue², Changxiu Shao¹, Yongxiang Liu¹, Jing Xu², Xiaolei Li²^,^†()

^1. Postgraduate Training Base of Jinzhou Medical University, The 960th Hospital of People′s Liberation Army, Jinzhou 121000, China; Department of Thyroid and Breast Surgery, The 960th Hospital of People′s Liberation Army, Jinan 250031, China
^2. Department of Thyroid and Breast Surgery, The 960th Hospital of People′s Liberation Army, Jinan 250031, China

Received:2022-02-17 Published:2022-10-30
Corresponding author: Xiaolei Li

全文 ( ) 下载PDF ( ) 导出引用

引用本文：

李陈钰, 贺青卿, 庄大勇, 周鹏, 岳涛, 邵长秀, 刘永祥, 徐婧, 李小磊. 经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术的学习曲线分析[J/OL]. 中华腔镜外科杂志(电子版), 2022, 15(05): 270-274.

Chenyu Li, Qingqing He, Dayong Zhuang, Peng Zhou, Tao Yue, Changxiu Shao, Yongxiang Liu, Jing Xu, Xiaolei Li. A prospective study of learning curve of transoral robotic thyroidectomy[J/OL]. Chinese Journal of Laparoscopic Surgery(Electronic Edition), 2022, 15(05): 270-274.

目的

探讨经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术(transoral robotic thyroidectomy, TORT)的学习曲线。

方法

前瞻性收集并分析2020年4月至2021年11月期间，就诊于解放军联勤保障部队第九六〇医院行TORT的70例患者的临床数据。采用累积和分析法拟合学习曲线，根据累积和值分为学习阶段和熟练阶段，探讨两个阶段的临床数据资料。

结果

70例患者均顺利完成TORT，无中转开放手术，手术时间129～490 min，平均(223.82±72.05)min；随访时间1～20个月，平均(10.23±5.43)个月；均无复发转移。选择并收集70例中连续进行的50例行甲状腺腺叶切除(含中央区淋巴结清扫)患者的临床数据进行统计分析，手术时间148～262 min，平均(205.68±57.59)min。采用累积和分析法发现，23例为跨越学习曲线掌握TORT的最低手术例数；学习阶段手术时间148～380 min，平均(238.17±63.32)min；熟练阶段手术时间134～262 min，平均(178±32.57)min。学习阶段和熟练阶段患者的手术时间比较，差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)；患者年龄、性别、肿瘤大小、中央区淋巴结清扫数、中央区淋巴结阳性数、术后拔管时间、并发症率比较，差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。

结论

对于经验丰富的外科医师，严格选择合适患者后，TORT是安全、可行的，跨越TORT学习曲线需要累积的最低手术例数为23例。

关键词: 甲状腺肿瘤, 达芬奇机器人手术系统, 经口腔前庭入路, 学习曲线, 累积和分析法

Objective

To investigate the learning curve of transoral robotic thyroidectomy.

Methods

From Apr. 2020 to Nov. 2021, the clinical data of 70 patients who had received transoral robotic thyroidectomy (TORT) at the 960th Hospital of PLA were gathered and studied prospectively. The cumulative sum analysis (CUSUM) was used to fit the learning curve. According to the CUSUM value, it was divided into learning stage and proficiency stage, and the clinical data of the two stages were analyzed.

Results

All the 70 patients successfully underwent TORT without conversion to open operation. The mean operation time was (223.82±72.05)min, 129- 490 min. There was no recurrence or metastasis after a mean follow-up time of (10.23±5.43)months, 1-20 months. The data of 50 consecutive cases of thyroidectomy (including central lymph node dissection) were selected and collected for statistical analysis. The mean operation time was (205.68 ± 57.59)min, 148-262 min. The lowest number of operations to master TORT and cross the learning curve was explored using CUSUM: the mean operation time in the learning stage was(238.17 ± 63.32)min, 148-380 min, and the mean operation time of proficiency stage was (178 ± 32.57) min, 134-262 min. There was significant difference in operation time between learning stage and proficiency stage(P<0.05); There was no significant difference in age, gender, tumor size, the number of dissect of lymph nodes, the number of lymph nodes positive in the central area, the extubation days after surgery, and the rate of complications between the two stages(P>0.05).

Conclusions

TORT is safe and feasible for expert surgeons who carefully choose appropriate patients. It′s a total of 23 operations that must be accumulated to cross the TORT learning curve.

Key words: Thyroid tumor, Da Vinci robotic surgery system, Transoral vestibular approach, Learning curve, Cumulative sum analysis

图1 70例行TORT患者中50例单侧腺叶切除(含中央区淋巴结清扫)的手术时间累积和学习曲线注：经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术(transoral robotic thyroidectomy, TORT)

表1 70例行TORT患者中50例单侧腺叶切除(含中央区淋巴结清扫)的学习阶段与熟练阶段的一般资料及围手术期数据

项目		学习阶段(23例)	熟练阶段(27例)	P值
性别[例(%)]				0.674
	男	2(8.7)	4(14.8)
	女	21(91.3)	23(85.2)
年龄(岁，±s)		30.91±9.66	30.37±8.36	0.836
体质量指数(kg/m²，±s)		23.08±3.60	22.53±4.10	0.629
手术方式[例(%)]
	腺叶	4(17.4)	4(14.8)	0.804
	腺叶＋中央区	19(82.6)	23(85.2)	0．804
病理性质[例(%)]
	乳头状癌	19(82.6)	23(85.2)	0.804
	滤泡性腺瘤	4(17.4)	3(11.1)	0．689
	结节性甲状腺肿	0(0.0)	1(3.7)	>0.999
恶性肿瘤直径(cm，±s)		0.48±0.20	0.55±0.24	0.876
中央区淋巴结清扫数(枚，±s)		10±3.92	10±3.91	0.948
中央区阳性淋巴结数(枚，±s)		2.11±1.20	3.36±3.34	0.552
术后拔管时间(d，±s)		5.17±0.96	5.52±1.20	0.283
手术时间(min，±s)		238.17±63.32	178±32.57	<0.001

表1 70例行TORT患者中50例单侧腺叶切除(含中央区淋巴结清扫)的学习阶段与熟练阶段的一般资料及围手术期数据

项目		学习阶段(23例)	熟练阶段(27例)	P值
性别[例(%)]				0.674
	男	2(8.7)	4(14.8)
	女	21(91.3)	23(85.2)
年龄(岁，±s)		30.91±9.66	30.37±8.36	0.836
体质量指数(kg/m²，±s)		23.08±3.60	22.53±4.10	0.629
手术方式[例(%)]
	腺叶	4(17.4)	4(14.8)	0.804
	腺叶＋中央区	19(82.6)	23(85.2)	0．804
病理性质[例(%)]
	乳头状癌	19(82.6)	23(85.2)	0.804
	滤泡性腺瘤	4(17.4)	3(11.1)	0．689
	结节性甲状腺肿	0(0.0)	1(3.7)	>0.999
恶性肿瘤直径(cm，±s)		0.48±0.20	0.55±0.24	0.876
中央区淋巴结清扫数(枚，±s)		10±3.92	10±3.91	0.948
中央区阳性淋巴结数(枚，±s)		2.11±1.20	3.36±3.34	0.552
术后拔管时间(d，±s)		5.17±0.96	5.52±1.20	0.283
手术时间(min，±s)		238.17±63.32	178±32.57	<0.001

1	Sung H, Ferlay J, Siegel RL, et al. Global cancer statistics 2020: GLOBOCAN estimates of incidence and mortality worldwide for 36 cancers in 185 countries[J]. CA Cancer J Clin, 2021, 71(3): 209-249.
2	Kim WW, Lee J, Jung JH, et al. A comparison study of the transoral and bilateral axillo-breast approaches in robotic thyroidectomy[J]. J Surg Oncol, 2018, 118(3): 381-387.
3	Park D, Kim HY, Kim HK, et al. Institutional experience of 200 consecutive papillary thyroid carcinoma patients in transoral robotic thyroidectomy surgeries[J]. Head Neck, 2020, 42(8): 2106-2114.
4	李小磊，贺青卿，李陈钰. 经口腔前庭入路机器人甲状腺手术30例临床分析[J]. 中华外科杂志，2021, 59(12): 994-998.
5	吴国洋，林福生. 经口腔前庭入路腔镜甲状腺手术专家共识解读及争议[J]. 外科理论与实践，2019, 24(6): 495-497.
6	李欣，侯纯升，白洋. 单孔腹腔镜胆囊切除术的学习曲线：累积求和分析法[J]. 中国微创外科杂志，2016, 16(3): 241-244.
7	秦倩，时飞宇，孙祺. 达芬奇机器人手术系统辅助胃癌根治术的学习曲线[J]. 中华消化外科杂志，2019, 18(5): 459-465.
8	王平，燕海潮. 完全腔镜甲状腺癌手术并发症的防治[J]. 腹腔镜外科杂志，2012, 17(11): 806-809.
9	Nakayama M, Holsinger FC, Chevalier D, et al. The dawn of robotic surgery in otolaryngology-head and neck surgery[J]. Jpn J Clin Oncol, 2019, 49(5): 404-411.
10	Tomikawa M, Xu H, Hashizume M. Current status and prerequisites for natural orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES)[J]. Surg Today, 2010, 40(10): 909-916.
11	Mohan HM, O′riordan JM, Winter DC. Natural-orifice translumenal endoscopic surgery (NOTES): minimally invasive evolution or revolution[J]. Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech, 2013, 23(3): 244-250.
12	Moris DN, Bramis KJ, Mantonakis EI, et al. Surgery via natural orifices in human beings: yesterday, today, tomorrow[J]. Am J Surg, 2012, 204(1): 93-102.
13	Lee HY, You JY, Woo SU, et al. Transoral periosteal thyroidectomy: cadaver to human[J]. Surg Endosc, 2015, 29(4): 898-904.
14	Chai YJ, Kim HY, Kim HK, et al. Comparative analysis of 2 robotic thyroidectomy procedures: transoral versus bilateral axillo-breast approach[J]. Head Neck, 2018, 40(5): 886-892.
15	Chae S, Min SY, Park WS. Comparison study of robotic thyroidectomies through a bilateral axillo-breast approach and a transoral approach[J]. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A, 2020, 30(2): 175-182.
16	Tai DKC, Kim HY, Park D, et al. Obesity may not affect outcomes of transoral robotic thyroidectomy: subset analysis of 304 patients[J]. Laryngoscope, 2020, 130(5): 1343-1348.
17	张彬，韩宗辉，Bikash Rai. 经口腔达芬奇机器人甲状腺手术初步经验[J/CD]. 中华腔镜外科杂志(电子版), 2018, 11(4): 234-237.
18	Chen YH, Kim HY, Anuwong A, et al. Transoral robotic thyroidectomy versus transoral endoscopic thyroidectomy: a propensity-score-matched analysis of surgical outcomes[J]. Surg Endosc, 2021, 35(11): 6179-6189.
19	Lee J, Yun JH, Nam KH, et al. The learning curve for robotic thyroidectomy: a multicenter study[J]. Ann Surg Oncol, 2011, 18(1): 226-232.
20	Luo JH, Xiang C, Wang P, et al. The learning curve for transoral endoscopic thyroid surgery: a single surgeon′s 204 case experience[J]. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A, 2020, 30(2): 163-169.

[1]	孙莲, 马红萍, 吴文英. 局部进展期甲状腺癌患者外科处理[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2025, 19(01): 112-114.
[2]	麻紫月, 王贞文, 张强, 赵代伟, 张翊伦. 右侧喉不返神经1例报告[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2025, 19(01): 115-116.
[3]	顾雯, 凌守鑫, 唐海利, 甘雪梅. 两种不同手术入路在甲状腺乳头状癌患者开放性根治性术中的应用比较[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(06): 687-690.
[4]	田文. 甲状腺癌功能性根治颈淋巴结清扫术[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 482-482.
[5]	王宇, 徐芳泉, 周旋, 姚晓峰, 李强. 不断提高分化型甲状腺癌根治性切除规范化[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 473-476.
[6]	孙辉, 李长霖. 分化型甲状腺癌根治性切除术中的关键考量与策略[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 477-481.
[7]	高一飞, 刘根祥, 孙长华, 周广军. 喉返神经监测在无充气腋窝入路腔镜单侧甲状腺切除+中央区淋巴结清扫术中的应用效果[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 483-486.
[8]	李云龙, 夏旭良, 江志强, 刘伟, 刘凯, 唐立, 刘昊中, 张思远. 三种方法治疗分化型甲状腺癌的临床疗效[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 487-489.
[9]	韩婧, 郝少龙, 康骅. 北京市单中心甲状腺癌患者临床特征的回顾分析[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(05): 490-493.
[10]	何羽. 腔镜微创手术治疗分化型甲状腺癌的研究进展[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(04): 456-458.
[11]	宋红霞, 吴玩呈. 内镜下甲状腺手术切口入路发展的研究进展[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(04): 470-472.
[12]	游涛建, 任林, 马宇. cT_1-2N₀期PTMC经口腔前庭入路腔镜甲状腺切除术后引流与否的可行性研究[J/OL]. 中华普外科手术学杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(03): 311-314.
[13]	江东根, 依力夏提·艾力, 依布拉音江·阿布力克木, 依力盼·依拉木, 冯瑶, 艾尼玩·木拉克, 艾克拜尔江·阿里木. 基层医院单一术者改良单通道腹腔镜下鞘状突环扎术学习曲线及体会[J/OL]. 中华腔镜泌尿外科杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(06): 560-565.
[14]	张斌, 孙代宇, 胡昕, 韩菲, 李久明, 李功雨, 吴伟力, 冯宝富, 彭国辉. 评分系统预测不同经验手术者输尿管软镜术后结石清除率准确性的比较研究[J/OL]. 中华腔镜泌尿外科杂志(电子版), 2024, 18(04): 353-360.
[15]	邵佳申, 张志武, 孟海, 杨雍, 费琦. 单侧双通道脊柱内镜技术治疗腰椎管狭窄症的临床疗效和学习曲线研究[J/OL]. 中华老年骨科与康复电子杂志, 2024, 10(04): 202-208.

阅读次数

全文

摘要

选择文件类型/文献管理软件名称

选择包含的内容

A prospective study of learning curve of transoral robotic thyroidectomy

模态框（Modal）标题

选择文件类型/文献管理软件名称

选择包含的内容

A prospective study of learning curve of transoral robotic thyroidectomy